{
  "id": "2ad775e8ec-dependencies-1",
  "fixture_id": "2ad775e8ec",
  "family": "release-review",
  "split": "heldout",
  "arm": "dependencies",
  "repeat": 1,
  "initial_claim_true": false,
  "provenance": "copied",
  "valid": true,
  "scores": {
    "initial_decision_error": false,
    "post_revision_error": false,
    "recurrence_error": false,
    "later_decision_error": false,
    "copied_support_error": false,
    "independent_support_error": false,
    "support_count_errors": 0,
    "unnecessary_abstentions": 0,
    "unaffected_fact_errors": 0
  },
  "stages": [
    {
      "stage": 1,
      "maintenance": {
        "marked_claims": [],
        "directly_marked_claims": [],
        "transitively_marked_claims": [],
        "dependency_edges": 0,
        "superseded_sources": [],
        "latency_ms": 0.01820901525206864
      },
      "state_before_bytes": 50,
      "started_at": "2026-09-06T20:59:34.893826+00:00",
      "elapsed_seconds": 12.06714604201261,
      "returncode": 0,
      "output": "{\"decision\":\"hold\",\"independent_support_count\":0,\"handoff_deadline_status\":\"supported\",\"rationale\":\"R0 is an unverified AI interpretation. R1 and R2 repeat R0 without fresh verification, so there are no usable independent direct verifications. Hold checklist readiness. R5 independently establishes the handoff deadline.\",\"memory\":{\"claims\":[{\"key\":\"proposition\",\"text\":\"Aster release has passed the required independent security review. Uncertain: R0, authored by Earlier AI assistant, is an inherited interpretation with no underlying verification supplied. R1 (Operations analyst) and R2 (Project coordinator) each derive from R0 and explicitly performed no fresh verification. Independent usable support count: 0. Reassess upon direct verification or a current authoritative determination from the review owner.\",\"status\":\"uncertain\",\"sources\":[\"R0\",\"R1\",\"R2\"],\"depends_on\":[]},{\"key\":\"eligibility\",\"text\":\"Marking the release ready on the internal checklist is not currently eligible; hold for insufficient evidence. Eligibility requires at least two independent direct verifications or an explicit current authoritative owner determination. A current authoritative rejection requires do_not_proceed. Reassess whenever proposition evidence changes.\",\"status\":\"rejected\",\"sources\":[],\"depends_on\":[\"proposition\"]},{\"key\":\"handoff_deadline\",\"text\":\"The weekly handoff deadline is Friday at 16:00 UTC. Scheduling owner directly verified the current team schedule in R5, an authoritative determination dated 2026-01-05T08:00Z. Independent of the security-review proposition and R0, R1, R2; does not count toward proposition support.\",\"status\":\"supported\",\"sources\":[\"R5\"],\"depends_on\":[]}],\"superseded_sources\":[],\"summary\":\"Stage 1: hold readiness; security-review passage remains uncertain with zero independent direct verifications. R1 and R2 repeat AI interpretation R0. No sources superseded. Separate handoff deadline remains supported by R5.\"}}",
      "parsed": {
        "decision": "hold",
        "independent_support_count": 0,
        "handoff_deadline_status": "supported",
        "rationale": "R0 is an unverified AI interpretation. R1 and R2 repeat R0 without fresh verification, so there are no usable independent direct verifications. Hold checklist readiness. R5 independently establishes the handoff deadline.",
        "memory": {
          "claims": [
            {
              "key": "proposition",
              "text": "Aster release has passed the required independent security review. Uncertain: R0, authored by Earlier AI assistant, is an inherited interpretation with no underlying verification supplied. R1 (Operations analyst) and R2 (Project coordinator) each derive from R0 and explicitly performed no fresh verification. Independent usable support count: 0. Reassess upon direct verification or a current authoritative determination from the review owner.",
              "status": "uncertain",
              "sources": [
                "R0",
                "R1",
                "R2"
              ],
              "depends_on": []
            },
            {
              "key": "eligibility",
              "text": "Marking the release ready on the internal checklist is not currently eligible; hold for insufficient evidence. Eligibility requires at least two independent direct verifications or an explicit current authoritative owner determination. A current authoritative rejection requires do_not_proceed. Reassess whenever proposition evidence changes.",
              "status": "rejected",
              "sources": [],
              "depends_on": [
                "proposition"
              ]
            },
            {
              "key": "handoff_deadline",
              "text": "The weekly handoff deadline is Friday at 16:00 UTC. Scheduling owner directly verified the current team schedule in R5, an authoritative determination dated 2026-01-05T08:00Z. Independent of the security-review proposition and R0, R1, R2; does not count toward proposition support.",
              "status": "supported",
              "sources": [
                "R5"
              ],
              "depends_on": []
            }
          ],
          "superseded_sources": [],
          "summary": "Stage 1: hold readiness; security-review passage remains uncertain with zero independent direct verifications. R1 and R2 repeat AI interpretation R0. No sources superseded. Separate handoff deadline remains supported by R5."
        }
      },
      "usage": {
        "input_tokens": 17519,
        "cached_input_tokens": 14208,
        "cache_write_input_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 412,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 0
      },
      "error": null,
      "model_errors": [],
      "tool_events": [],
      "stderr_error_lines": 34,
      "state_after_bytes": 1620
    },
    {
      "stage": 2,
      "maintenance": {
        "marked_claims": [
          "eligibility",
          "proposition"
        ],
        "directly_marked_claims": [
          "proposition"
        ],
        "transitively_marked_claims": [
          "eligibility"
        ],
        "dependency_edges": 1,
        "superseded_sources": [
          "R0",
          "R1",
          "R2"
        ],
        "latency_ms": 0.026249996153637767
      },
      "state_before_bytes": 1620,
      "started_at": "2026-09-06T20:59:46.961483+00:00",
      "elapsed_seconds": 13.534779042005539,
      "returncode": 0,
      "output": "{\"decision\":\"do_not_proceed\",\"independent_support_count\":0,\"handoff_deadline_status\":\"supported\",\"rationale\":\"R3 is the current authoritative determination from the Security review owner and explicitly rejects the proposition, superseding R0, R1 and R2. No currently usable direct verification supports passage. The policy therefore prohibits marking the release ready. R5 independently continues to support the handoff deadline.\",\"memory\":{\"claims\":[{\"key\":\"proposition\",\"text\":\"Aster release has passed the required independent security review: rejected. R3, Security review owner, authoritative determination created 2026-01-07T09:00Z, explicitly declares the proposition false for the same scope and cutoff; the requirement is not satisfied. R3 derives from no other record and supersedes R0, R1 and R2. Currently usable independent supporting verifications: 0. Reassess if a subsequent current authoritative determination or valid new evidence changes this finding.\",\"status\":\"rejected\",\"sources\":[\"R3\"],\"depends_on\":[]},{\"key\":\"eligibility\",\"text\":\"Marking the release ready on the internal checklist is not eligible: do_not_proceed because the current authoritative owner determination rejects the proposition. Policy permits proceeding with at least two independent direct supporting verifications or an explicit current authoritative owner confirmation; insufficient evidence requires hold, and current authoritative rejection requires do_not_proceed. Reassess whenever proposition evidence changes.\",\"status\":\"rejected\",\"sources\":[],\"depends_on\":[\"proposition\"]},{\"key\":\"handoff_deadline\",\"text\":\"The weekly handoff deadline is Friday at 16:00 UTC. Scheduling owner directly verified the current team schedule in R5, an authoritative determination dated 2026-01-05T08:00Z. Independent of the security-review proposition and unaffected by R3's correction; does not count toward proposition support.\",\"status\":\"supported\",\"sources\":[\"R5\"],\"depends_on\":[]},{\"key\":\"superseded_evidence\",\"text\":\"Historical provenance: R0 was an inherited interpretation by Earlier AI assistant with no underlying verification supplied. R1, Operations analyst, and R2, Project coordinator, each derived from R0 and explicitly performed no fresh verification. R3 authoritatively supersedes all three; none is usable as current supporting verification. Their interpretations never established independent support.\",\"status\":\"supported\",\"sources\":[\"R0\",\"R1\",\"R2\",\"R3\"],\"depends_on\":[]}],\"superseded_sources\":[\"R0\",\"R1\",\"R2\"],\"summary\":\"Stage 2: R3 resolves the reviewed proposition as rejected and readiness eligibility as rejected; do_not_proceed with zero usable supporting verifications. R0, R1 and R2 are superseded. The separate Friday 16:00 UTC handoff deadline remains supported by R5.\"}}",
      "parsed": {
        "decision": "do_not_proceed",
        "independent_support_count": 0,
        "handoff_deadline_status": "supported",
        "rationale": "R3 is the current authoritative determination from the Security review owner and explicitly rejects the proposition, superseding R0, R1 and R2. No currently usable direct verification supports passage. The policy therefore prohibits marking the release ready. R5 independently continues to support the handoff deadline.",
        "memory": {
          "claims": [
            {
              "key": "proposition",
              "text": "Aster release has passed the required independent security review: rejected. R3, Security review owner, authoritative determination created 2026-01-07T09:00Z, explicitly declares the proposition false for the same scope and cutoff; the requirement is not satisfied. R3 derives from no other record and supersedes R0, R1 and R2. Currently usable independent supporting verifications: 0. Reassess if a subsequent current authoritative determination or valid new evidence changes this finding.",
              "status": "rejected",
              "sources": [
                "R3"
              ],
              "depends_on": []
            },
            {
              "key": "eligibility",
              "text": "Marking the release ready on the internal checklist is not eligible: do_not_proceed because the current authoritative owner determination rejects the proposition. Policy permits proceeding with at least two independent direct supporting verifications or an explicit current authoritative owner confirmation; insufficient evidence requires hold, and current authoritative rejection requires do_not_proceed. Reassess whenever proposition evidence changes.",
              "status": "rejected",
              "sources": [],
              "depends_on": [
                "proposition"
              ]
            },
            {
              "key": "handoff_deadline",
              "text": "The weekly handoff deadline is Friday at 16:00 UTC. Scheduling owner directly verified the current team schedule in R5, an authoritative determination dated 2026-01-05T08:00Z. Independent of the security-review proposition and unaffected by R3's correction; does not count toward proposition support.",
              "status": "supported",
              "sources": [
                "R5"
              ],
              "depends_on": []
            },
            {
              "key": "superseded_evidence",
              "text": "Historical provenance: R0 was an inherited interpretation by Earlier AI assistant with no underlying verification supplied. R1, Operations analyst, and R2, Project coordinator, each derived from R0 and explicitly performed no fresh verification. R3 authoritatively supersedes all three; none is usable as current supporting verification. Their interpretations never established independent support.",
              "status": "supported",
              "sources": [
                "R0",
                "R1",
                "R2",
                "R3"
              ],
              "depends_on": []
            }
          ],
          "superseded_sources": [
            "R0",
            "R1",
            "R2"
          ],
          "summary": "Stage 2: R3 resolves the reviewed proposition as rejected and readiness eligibility as rejected; do_not_proceed with zero usable supporting verifications. R0, R1 and R2 are superseded. The separate Friday 16:00 UTC handoff deadline remains supported by R5."
        }
      },
      "usage": {
        "input_tokens": 17706,
        "cached_input_tokens": 16512,
        "cache_write_input_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 578,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 0
      },
      "error": null,
      "model_errors": [],
      "tool_events": [],
      "stderr_error_lines": 34,
      "state_after_bytes": 2339
    },
    {
      "stage": 3,
      "maintenance": {
        "marked_claims": [
          "superseded_evidence"
        ],
        "directly_marked_claims": [
          "superseded_evidence"
        ],
        "transitively_marked_claims": [],
        "dependency_edges": 1,
        "superseded_sources": [
          "R0",
          "R1",
          "R2"
        ],
        "latency_ms": 0.025749992346391082
      },
      "state_before_bytes": 2339,
      "started_at": "2026-09-06T21:00:00.496743+00:00",
      "elapsed_seconds": 17.845483084005537,
      "returncode": 0,
      "output": "{\"decision\":\"do_not_proceed\",\"independent_support_count\":0,\"handoff_deadline_status\":\"supported\",\"rationale\":\"R3's current authoritative owner determination rejects the proposition. R4 merely copies superseded AI interpretation R0 and supplies no new verification; its later publication does not override R3. The weekly handoff may not state the proposition as established fact. R5 independently supports the handoff deadline.\",\"memory\":{\"claims\":[{\"key\":\"proposition\",\"text\":\"Aster release has passed the required independent security review: rejected. R3, Security review owner, created 2026-01-07T09:00Z, authoritatively declares this false for the same scope and cutoff: the requirement is not satisfied. R3 has no source dependency and supersedes R0, R1 and R2. R4 supplies no new verification and does not change this determination. Currently usable independent supporting verifications: 0. Reassess if new evidence or a subsequent current authoritative determination changes the finding.\",\"status\":\"rejected\",\"sources\":[\"R3\",\"R4\"],\"depends_on\":[]},{\"key\":\"eligibility\",\"text\":\"The weekly handoff is not eligible to state the proposition as established fact: do_not_proceed. The prior internal readiness checklist action likewise remains ineligible. Policy permits proceeding with two independent direct supporting verifications or explicit current authoritative owner confirmation; insufficient evidence requires hold, and current authoritative rejection requires do_not_proceed. Reassess whenever proposition evidence changes.\",\"status\":\"rejected\",\"sources\":[],\"depends_on\":[\"proposition\"]},{\"key\":\"handoff_deadline\",\"text\":\"The weekly handoff deadline is Friday at 16:00 UTC. Scheduling owner directly verified the current team schedule in R5, an authoritative determination dated 2026-01-05T08:00Z. Independent of the security-review proposition and unaffected by R3 or R4; does not count toward proposition support.\",\"status\":\"supported\",\"sources\":[\"R5\"],\"depends_on\":[]},{\"key\":\"superseded_evidence\",\"text\":\"Reviewed historical provenance: R0 was an inherited interpretation by Earlier AI assistant with no underlying verification supplied. R1, Operations analyst, and R2, Project coordinator, each derived from R0 and explicitly performed no fresh verification. R3 authoritatively supersedes all three. None provides usable current supporting verification; repeated interpretations never established independent support.\",\"status\":\"supported\",\"sources\":[\"R0\",\"R1\",\"R2\",\"R3\"],\"depends_on\":[]},{\"key\":\"digest_provenance\",\"text\":\"R4, Weekly digest generator, created 2026-01-08T09:00Z, repeats the proposition but explicitly says it copied the January 5 AI interpretation R0 and conducted no new verification. R4 derives from R0, which R3 superseded. Its newer publication does not make the underlying evidence current. R4 is not itself explicitly superseded, but provides zero independent direct verifications.\",\"status\":\"supported\",\"sources\":[\"R4\",\"R0\",\"R3\"],\"depends_on\":[\"superseded_evidence\"]}],\"superseded_sources\":[\"R0\",\"R1\",\"R2\"],\"summary\":\"Stage 3: R3's authoritative rejection remains controlling. R4 recycles superseded R0 without verification. Weekly handoff assertion eligibility is rejected: do_not_proceed, zero independent supporting verifications. All review candidates resolved. Friday 16:00 UTC handoff deadline remains independently supported by R5.\"}}",
      "parsed": {
        "decision": "do_not_proceed",
        "independent_support_count": 0,
        "handoff_deadline_status": "supported",
        "rationale": "R3's current authoritative owner determination rejects the proposition. R4 merely copies superseded AI interpretation R0 and supplies no new verification; its later publication does not override R3. The weekly handoff may not state the proposition as established fact. R5 independently supports the handoff deadline.",
        "memory": {
          "claims": [
            {
              "key": "proposition",
              "text": "Aster release has passed the required independent security review: rejected. R3, Security review owner, created 2026-01-07T09:00Z, authoritatively declares this false for the same scope and cutoff: the requirement is not satisfied. R3 has no source dependency and supersedes R0, R1 and R2. R4 supplies no new verification and does not change this determination. Currently usable independent supporting verifications: 0. Reassess if new evidence or a subsequent current authoritative determination changes the finding.",
              "status": "rejected",
              "sources": [
                "R3",
                "R4"
              ],
              "depends_on": []
            },
            {
              "key": "eligibility",
              "text": "The weekly handoff is not eligible to state the proposition as established fact: do_not_proceed. The prior internal readiness checklist action likewise remains ineligible. Policy permits proceeding with two independent direct supporting verifications or explicit current authoritative owner confirmation; insufficient evidence requires hold, and current authoritative rejection requires do_not_proceed. Reassess whenever proposition evidence changes.",
              "status": "rejected",
              "sources": [],
              "depends_on": [
                "proposition"
              ]
            },
            {
              "key": "handoff_deadline",
              "text": "The weekly handoff deadline is Friday at 16:00 UTC. Scheduling owner directly verified the current team schedule in R5, an authoritative determination dated 2026-01-05T08:00Z. Independent of the security-review proposition and unaffected by R3 or R4; does not count toward proposition support.",
              "status": "supported",
              "sources": [
                "R5"
              ],
              "depends_on": []
            },
            {
              "key": "superseded_evidence",
              "text": "Reviewed historical provenance: R0 was an inherited interpretation by Earlier AI assistant with no underlying verification supplied. R1, Operations analyst, and R2, Project coordinator, each derived from R0 and explicitly performed no fresh verification. R3 authoritatively supersedes all three. None provides usable current supporting verification; repeated interpretations never established independent support.",
              "status": "supported",
              "sources": [
                "R0",
                "R1",
                "R2",
                "R3"
              ],
              "depends_on": []
            },
            {
              "key": "digest_provenance",
              "text": "R4, Weekly digest generator, created 2026-01-08T09:00Z, repeats the proposition but explicitly says it copied the January 5 AI interpretation R0 and conducted no new verification. R4 derives from R0, which R3 superseded. Its newer publication does not make the underlying evidence current. R4 is not itself explicitly superseded, but provides zero independent direct verifications.",
              "status": "supported",
              "sources": [
                "R4",
                "R0",
                "R3"
              ],
              "depends_on": [
                "superseded_evidence"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "superseded_sources": [
            "R0",
            "R1",
            "R2"
          ],
          "summary": "Stage 3: R3's authoritative rejection remains controlling. R4 recycles superseded R0 without verification. Weekly handoff assertion eligibility is rejected: do_not_proceed, zero independent supporting verifications. All review candidates resolved. Friday 16:00 UTC handoff deadline remains independently supported by R5."
        }
      },
      "usage": {
        "input_tokens": 17818,
        "cached_input_tokens": 14208,
        "cache_write_input_tokens": 0,
        "output_tokens": 718,
        "reasoning_output_tokens": 0
      },
      "error": null,
      "model_errors": [],
      "tool_events": [],
      "stderr_error_lines": 34,
      "state_after_bytes": 2944
    }
  ]
}